“The Making of a Pop Sensation: ‘Big Girls Don’t Cry’ by Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons”

About The Song

Background

Released in 1962, “Big Girls Don’t Cry” became a signature song for The Four Seasons, a doo-wop vocal group led by the iconic falsetto of Frankie Valli. The song’s success solidified the group’s place as one of the hottest acts of the early 1960s.

The songwriting team of Bob Crewe and Bob Gaudio, who penned many of The Four Seasons’ hits, crafted “Big Girls Don’t Cry.” Their collaboration was a perfect match. Crewe, a lyricist with a knack for capturing teenage emotions, provided the heartfelt words. Gaudio, a skilled musician, composed the catchy melody.

Musical Style

“Big Girls Don’t Cry” is a prime example of the doo-wop genre, a style that originated in African American vocal groups of the 1940s and 50s. Doo-wop is characterized by tight vocal harmonies, often featuring a high tenor lead (like Valli’s falsetto) and rhythmic backing vocals. The song utilizes a simple yet effective instrumentation, typically consisting of piano, bass, and drums.

However, “Big Girls Don’t Cry” also incorporates elements of the emerging “blue-eyed soul” sound. This subgenre featured white singers adopting the soulful stylings of African American R&B artists like Ray Charles and The Drifters. Valli’s emotive vocals and the song’s underlying sadness reflect this influence.

The structure of “Big Girls Don’t Cry” is straightforward. It follows a verse-chorus-bridge format, with the catchy chorus “Big girls don’t cry / (They don’t cry) / Big girls don’t cry / (Who said they don’t cry?)” repeated throughout. The use of call and response between Valli’s lead and the backing vocals further adds to the song’s dynamism.

Lyrics

The lyrics of “Big Girls Don’t Cry” tell the story of a young man regretting a break-up. The narrator, portrayed by Valli, arrogantly tells his girlfriend they have to part ways, expecting her to be upset. However, she surprises him by holding back her tears and simply saying, “Big girls don’t cry.” This unexpected response leaves the narrator feeling foolish and remorseful.

The song delves into complex teenage emotions. The narrator’s initial bravado masks his insecurity, and the girl’s composure hides her pain. The lyrics, though simple, capture the confusion and heartache of young love. Lines like “Silly boy / Told my girl we had to break up / Silly boy / Thought that she would call my bluff” showcase the narrator’s naivete, while the repeated “Big girls don’t cry” reflects a societal pressure on women to suppress their emotions.

Cultural Impact

“Big Girls Don’t Cry” became an instant smash hit. It reached number one on the Billboard Hot 100 chart in November 1962, spending five weeks at the top. This success followed their previous single, “Sherry,” which also held the number one spot for five weeks. The Four Seasons became pop music sensations, their sound resonating with teenagers across America. “Big Girls Don’t Cry” solidified the group’s place as a major force in the early 1960s music scene.

The song’s cultural impact extends beyond the charts. “Big Girls Don’t Cry” became a cultural touchstone, referenced in movies, television shows, and even literature. The iconic title phrase became ingrained in popular culture, challenging traditional gender expectations and sparking conversations about emotional expression.

However, the lyrics have also been subject to debate. Some argue that the message discourages women from openly expressing their feelings. While the song reflects societal norms of the time, it has undoubtedly sparked discussions about emotional vulnerability and authenticity.

Conclusion

“Big Girls Don’t Cry” is more than just a catchy pop song. It’s a cultural touchstone that captured the complexities of teenage love and challenged societal expectations. The song’s enduring popularity lies not only in its infectious melody and soulful vocals, but also in its timeless themes of heartbreak, regret, and the search for emotional connection.

Video

Lyrics